Environmental Refugees Unable to Return Home
IRP Fellow reports for the New York Times
Fellows Fall 2009
January 04, 2010
Appeared in The New York Times
Mahe Noor, left, and Nizam Hawladar with two of their children in Dhaka, Bangladesh. A cyclone two years ago uprooted them from a village where they had their livelihood.
DHAKA, BANGLADESH "” Mahe Noor left her village in southern Bangladesh after Cyclone Sidr flattened her family's home and small market in 2007. Jobless and homeless, she and her husband, Nizam Hawladar, moved to this crowded megalopolis, hoping that they might soon return home.
Two years later, they are still here. Ms. Noor, 25, and Mr. Hawladar, 35, work long hours at low-paying jobs "” she at a garment factory and he at a roadside tea stall. They are unable to save money after paying for food and rent on their dark shanty in Korail, one of the largest slums in Dhaka. And in their village, more people are leaving because of river erosion and dwindling job opportunities.
"We're trapped," Ms. Noor said.
Natural calamities have plagued humanity for generations. But with the prospect of worsening climate conditions over the next few decades, experts on migration say tens of millions more people in the developing world could be on the move because of disasters.
"Environmental refugees have lost everything," said Rabab Fatima, the South Asia representative of the International Organization for Migration. "They don't have the money to make a big move. They move to the next village, the next town and eventually to a city."
Story as it appears on page 1A of the International Herald Tribune (the global edition of The New York Times) - Asia (01/04/10).
Such rapid and unplanned urbanization is expected to put even further strains on scarce water, energy and food resources, said Koko Warner, who works in environmental migration at the United Nations University Institute for Environment and Human Security in Bonn.
In Bangladesh, a largely flat, riverine nation where more than 140 million people live in one of the most densely populated countries in the world, past generations often moved to cities seasonally. They worked to send money home to their villages and usually returned there during planting season.
But in recent years, the moves are more likely to be permanent. More intense storms and floods, salinization damage to crops caused by the encroaching sea and especially worsening river erosion have left many people rootless, Ms. Fatima said.
Dhaka, the capital, is often the only real option in this region. It is the fastest-growing megacity in the world, according to the World Bank. At least 12 million people live in Dhaka, and there are more than 400,000 newcomers each year. The World Bank predicts that the population could grow dramatically by 2020.
Like the rest of Bangladesh, Dhaka is also extremely vulnerable to climate change: It is just a few meters above sea level and is regularly hit by cyclones and floods. The environmental group WWF recently rated it among the megacities most vulnerable to the effects of global warming, after Jakarta and Manila.
As many as half of the people in Dhaka live in shantytowns and slums, says Atiq Rahman, a climate change researcher and executive director of the Bangladesh Center for Advanced Studies. Of those, Mr. Rahman and Ms. Fatima estimate that three million people have been displaced by environmental degradation or disasters.
The most destitute people live in clusters of improvised tents made of plastic sheets and discarded bamboo and often erected on private land near markets, railroad tracks and the city's rivers.
Most poor, working-class families end up in minicities like Korail, where Ms. Noor, the migrant from southern Bangladesh, lives with her husband and two daughters. Ms. Noor's third child, a son, lives with his grandmother in the family's village.
Korail sits on public land and is shared by at least 40,000 people crowded into cramped, cockroach-infested rental shanties made of mud, bamboo and corrugated tin.
Barefoot children play with broken marbles on narrow mud lanes filled with garbage and streams of raw sewage. A few enterprising residents have opened vegetable stands, tailor shops, carpentry mills and teahouses in tiny shacks.
Aid groups run primary schools in Korail and other slums, but many children work or stay home to mind younger siblings while their parents work.
Child trafficking and arson are serious problems, experts here say. Ms. Noor says she worries she will come home one day and find her young daughters kidnapped, or worse.
"Every day I hear about a fire or about someone's child missing," Ms. Noor said.
Ms. Noor's next-door neighbor, Aklima Akhter, 22, also lost her home and her family's small market in her southern Bangladesh village to flooding caused by Cyclone Sidr.
Story as it appears on page 1A of the International Herald Tribune (the global edition of The New York Times) - Europe (01/04/10).
Another neighbor, Mukhles Rahman, 38, and his brother Mohammad Farid Uddin, 56, left their village of Chawlakathi in the division of Barisal eight years ago because of river erosion.
Their family once grew rice, jute, sugar cane, mustard seed and radishes on four hectares, or 10 acres. Over a couple of decades, the Sandhya River washed away the farmland and the family home.
"My father could cross the river just by jumping across," said Mr. Uddin, who finished high school and ran a small school in his village. "Even when I was a youngster in the 1960s, we could swim across. Now it's so big."
These days, the two brothers live in a tiny shanty with Mukhles Rahman's wife and young son.
"We are trying to find another place to go, because all the land back home is dissolving," said Mukhles Rahman, who works as a security guard at a garment factory. "But there aren't jobs in other cities or in villages."
For migrants displaced because of the environment, Bangladesh hopes to begin helping them find opportunities in cities other than Dhaka, said Saleemul Huq, a Bangladeshi scientist who is a senior fellow in the climate change group of the International Institute for Environment and Development in London.
Bangladesh and other countries hit hard by climate change are supposed to receive money from a $100 billion annual green climate fund approved by the negotiators at the Copenhagen summit meeting in December. Smaller amounts of aid have been pledged for the next few years. The larger amounts of environmental aid are not expected to begin flowing until 2020.
Later this year, Mr. Huq will open and lead the International Center for Climate Change and Development, an institute based just outside of Dhaka and aimed at helping vulnerable countries come up with practical ways to adapt to climate change.
"We are going to have low-lying areas in Bangladesh that are not going to be inhabitable anymore, so those people will have to go somewhere," Mr. Huq said. While Dhaka has managed to absorb millions of migrants, he said that this "can't go on forever. Dhaka can't take it, and neither can the people."
Rashida Akhter, a local manager for BRAC, a nongovernmental organization that operates across Bangladesh as well as in several other poor countries, says that more than 90 percent of the Korail slum's residents never leave because they cannot save enough money to move.
Ms. Noor and Mr. Hawladar say they cannot imagine growing old in a dank, depressing place like Korail. They still dream about returning to their home village of Nandikathi, a poor, waterlogged hamlet of about 3,000 people.
"It's our home, not Dhaka" Mr. Hawladar said.
Their 6-year-old son is in Nandikathi with his grandmother. They have not seen him for a year. If they lived there, their daughters, ages 8 and 3, would be able to go to school, instead of being stuck alone all day in a tiny rented shack.
Ms. Noor, who remembers a modest but more comfortable life in Nandikathi, talks about rebuilding the family's shattered hut and reviving her drowned backyard garden of greens and gourds.
Mr. Hawladar says he wants to open another market there and add a tea house. He was badly injured in a road accident a few years ago and cannot do physical labor, so he spends 15-hour days in a wooden roadside stall in an affluent Dhaka neighborhood, brewing tea for businessmen. He makes 150 taka, or $2, a day. Ms. Noor makes about $1 a day at the garment factory.
They count their earnings at night, in silence, on the wooden plank that serves as the family bed. They never have enough money.
Even if they could save enough money to rebuild their home, the prospects are bleak in Nandikathi. The nearby Dhanshiri River has become more unruly, eroding land and livelihoods.
Ms. Noor says she sometimes stays up until the morning, worrying that the next big flood will just wash the village away.
"Where will people live then?" she asked.
Joanna Kakissis reported with the help of a grant from the International Reporting Project. Sumon Kaiser of bdnews24.com contributed reporting.
More from this Reporter
- Bangladesh’s battle against climate change
- Challenges facing climate migrants
- Photo Gallery: Portraits of Southwestern Bangladesh